We Crossed Oceans for a Better Future, But Are We Still Parenting as Though We never Left Africa?
By: Kemi Seriki
We crossed continents in search of a better future for our children, but somewhere along the journey, did we forget that their greatest need was not simply a better life, but parents who were emotionally present in it?
Introduction:
In the present day of social media, one would often find a video post on Instagram or TikTok of children of African descent in the diaspora from America, Europe, and Canada commenting on their parents’ parenting skills and how the African parenting style is not meeting today’s standard or the standard of the society they are living in. These children are commenting on their parents not understanding the dynamic of the society they are raising children in, from racial struggle to their emotional and mental health struggles. What transpires after migrating from a society that embraces “We are all in this together” to one that relentlessly pursues the American dream? Or, can African immigrant parents in the diaspora prepare their children for life in America or in Europe if they keep parenting as if they never left their individual countries in Africa? There has to be a deeper discussion about finding the middle ground between achieving financial success and being emotionally available to our children in a culture unfamiliar to us. African immigrant parents do face challenges in raising their children in a culture that is quite different from their home country. While balancing parental responsibility and protecting their children in an unfamiliar culture, Immigrants parents often struggle between assimilating to the host culture or dismissing the host culture by retaining their traditions as a way of life within their homes.
Customary African Parenting Ideal:
Community involvement in raising a child is a widely practiced belief system on the African continent. The community’s culture is highly pronounced, from the extended family to larger community members who provide guidance and discipline when needed. There is a general belief that children are the responsibility of the whole community. The traditional practice of respect towards elders is not limited to your immediate family. Still, it extends to other members of the community, and the youth emulate what they see daily as they witness the older generation’s behavior towards elders. For example, in Yoruba culture, it is traditional practice to greet an older person by prostrating if you are male and kneeling if you are a female.
There are family responsibilities, and children are expected to help around the house from a very young age. These chores include sweeping, cooking, fetching water, and running errands, and they are usually assigned based on age and gender. The sense of responsibility also extends to community duties, and children are not exempt from collective obligations. As their community is responsible for their well-being, the children are also expected to contribute to that welfare. There is a general belief that this connection to the community would help the child develop social skills as they learn to cooperate, develop empathy, share, respect boundaries, develop manners, resolve conflict, and develop friendships within the age group. As a child receives guidance and support and is embraced by immediate family and community members, the child may also be disciplined by these groups when necessary. A child could be physically punished or lectured by their parents and community members for doing something wrong, without fear of retribution. In African multicultural society, it is uncommon to call police or legal authority on a child who misbehaves or resolve conflicts among youth. The intervention comes from the community, and as a Yoruba saying goes, “Àgbà kìí wà l’ọjà, kí orí ọmọ tuntun ó wọ,” meaning elders must not allow youth to go wayward without intervention or correction.
Challenges of Shifting to a New Model – Western Society
The African parenting model is the typical parenting knowledge that African immigrants are familiar with, and it can be challenging for many parents to adjust to an unfamiliar system. Parents in the diaspora miss the intervention of extended family and the communal support networks they are accustomed to in their countries of origin. Some members of the community may be lucky enough to have other family members or other people from their home country living nearby. If they do have someone in the area, that support system may not be available regularly because everyone is usually busy with their own lives. African immigrants are widely dispersed across cities and states, making it challenging to build communal support systems for child-rearing. It may also be challenging for some family to connect with others who do not share their cultural background for many reasons, including the fear of rejection, isolation & language barriers, discrimination, and mostly the fear of the unknown.
In many cases, African immigrants migrate to a new country with their children or marry and have children shortly after their arrival. An individual who migrates to a new country, rather than migrating as a family unit, may have a better opportunity to integrate, explore personal growth, and spend more time understanding the social dynamics of their new home. For most immigrants who migrate as a family unit, the focus is usually on survival and prioritizing family needs, which compromises individual exploration of the dynamics of the country they migrated to.
Generational Shift and Acculturation
Now, we have to talk about the cultural differences, intergenerational cultural conflict, and acculturational gap between parents and children. According to social scientists, Children tend to adapt more quickly to a new culture than their parents. They mingle with their peers and usually learn through academic exposure and acquire new social skills from schoolmates. For example, these children assimilate at such a fast pace that the language barrier and accent disappear within a short time. I have seen many children of immigrants become translators for their parents with language barriers in public spaces.
On the flip side, parents are sometimes shocked by their children’s rapid adaptation to social norms that are foreign and sometimes unacceptable, which tends to create conflict and disagreement within the household. I have learned to admire how children of immigrants tend to code-switch depending on the social setting, whether within the general population or within their own community. During many community conversations I have held with children of African immigrants, most of them express code-switching during our discussions. As one attendee stated, “When I am outside, I am American. When I come home, I drop my American identity by the front door and become a Ghanaian child.”
Academic and Material Success Vs Individual Talent
Most immigrants abroad dream of a better future for their children, and African immigrants are no exception to this drive. It stems from a lack of such opportunities in their home countries. As a result, their primary focus is education and high-skill job opportunities that would guarantee upward mobility for their children’s future. There is a familiar saying among the children of African immigrants regarding the career choice imposed on them by their parents and/or members of the community, which includes lawyer, doctor, and engineer. These professional areas are categorized as requiring higher intelligence than vocational or technical jobs, such as plumbing, auto repair, and electrical work, which are looked down upon. Africans tend to relate more to white-collar work that requires long-term, rigorous training and many years of schooling, and this stems from how we view successful careers. For many parents, professions such as lawyer, doctor, and engineer are seen as reputable, with a guaranteed livable income, and any other career choice would be considered a failure not only to the child but also to the parents, who may see themselves as failures.
Bragging Right:
To complete this essay, I must acknowledge the real reason African parents push for the “Holy Trinity” of medicine, law, and engineering. Bragging rights are the ultimate social currency for achievements involving their children within African immigrant communities in the diaspora and on the continent. Understandably, a child’s achievement is sometimes reflected in the parents’ sacrifices. Many of us migrated from a part of society that treated a child’s achievements as parents’ accomplishments, and from one where other professional or vocational training choices were considered mere achievements. This view is shaped by our experiences of what is considered a prideful achievement in our home countries. For example, in Nigeria, it is customary for parents to be called and addressed by the name of their first child. If the first-born’s name is Toyin, Chioma, Amina, or Adesusu, then the mother and father are called mama Toyin, baba Ngozi, mama Adesusu, etc. If any of these children later become doctors, the name may change to mama doctor or baba Lawyer. Other displays of bragging rights occur in social settings, such as boasting to others about their children’s professions, in religious ceremonies, and at community events celebrating milestones in these significant careers. I have yet to come across such celebration or prideful acknowledgment of those children who graduate from trade school among Africans in the diaspora.
Intelligence and Professions
As an immigrant, I have been curious to explore the diversity of career options and to look further into the relationship between intelligence and professional choice. A few years ago, I was having a conversation with two Nigerians who happened to be a lawyer and a medical doctor. We were discussing the unlimited professional choices in America, and both were bragging about their professions to prove their intelligence while looking down on skilled labor, such as plumbers and electricians. I indicated to them that your profession is limited to your area of specialty because you don’t have the skills to perform skilled labor, such as fixing a pipe or addressing electrical issues in your home or business. I commented on how exhausting it must be to carry all that intelligence around, especially since it apparently stops working the exact second you have an electrical fault or a broken pipe in your house. Suddenly you’re helplessly waiting for the ‘unskilled’ workers to save the day.
Since living in America for a few years, I have come to understand that perceptions of intelligence are socially constructed, and many social scientists have proven this point through research. And, just because someone went to a trade school does not necessarily mean they lack intelligence. People often unfairly assume that workers in skilled trades or manual labor are less intelligent. Society failed to recognize that carpentry, electricians, plumbing, auto mechanics, locksmiths, etc. require a special kind of intelligence, the ability to solve problems, and distinct knowledge. We must recognize that society functions through interconnectedness and that professions such as doctors, lawyers, and engineers could not function without the contributions of electricians who ensure electricity is operational, plumbers who maintain clean water and sanitation systems, and many other skilled occupations that make our lives easier.
In our African immigrant community, many of us associate happiness with external factors rather than with internal happiness. It is about material possessions such as impressive career choices, an expensive home that many cannot afford, a luxury car, designer outfits, and expensive jewelry. This material wealth, which brings temporary joy to our lives, leads to competition among ourselves and an unnecessary rat-race mentality of “keeping up with the Joneses”. To focus on internal happiness is to appreciate and practice contentment, and to find gratification in what one possesses without comparing oneself to others. When our energy is more focused on acquiring material wealth that is beyond our means, it requires that we work overtime, sometimes two or three jobs, and what energy is left in us to focus our attention on exploring a better relationship with our children, or even address our own physical and emotional health?
The Neglect of Emotional Intelligence and Emotional Support
A parent whose parenting style focuses more on promoting the child’s emotional intelligence than on academic achievement alone may later have an adult who has no problem regulating their emotions. According to studies, a child who lacks emotional support growing up may face challenges in adulthood in regulating emotions and forming healthy relationships in their personal and professional lives. I remember my recent conversation with a fellow African immigrant parent who said to me, “I assumed that giving my children a stable home, discipline and sense of responsibility, food, financial stability and good education was enough. I wasn’t aware they needed me to be present emotionally. I had to unlearn the belief that success is not about money and status. The parent further confessed that he had no idea what it is like to be present emotionally for his children until he agreed to participate in a family therapy session with his daughter. Through family therapy, he said he learned to actively listen and validate his daughter’s feelings, even when he may not necessarily agree. He said that he has cut back on talking, mostly during family conversations, and instead practices listening more. By listening more, he said he has developed empathy and come to understand from his daughter’s perspective, and this practice has brought them closer. Father revealed that his daughter is more open to talking to him about almost anything, and in some cases, she even discusses intimate matters she never discussed before.
As many psychologists have indicated, parents who do not have an open-door policy in their family relationship with their children to give a listening ear to their children for what emotional issues they are struggling with may eventually cause the child to seek help outside and sometimes from unhealthy sources.
Should We Blame the Society We Choose to Raise Our Children
Many immigrants who migrated to a new country did so by choice, and we can’t expect “It takes a village to raise a child” in the individualistic culture of the West. As parents, it is our responsibility to learn a new way of parenting while preserving our values as we integrate into a new society. We should also acknowledge that African immigrants’ parents are not homogenous or identical. Like many immigrants from Asia, South America, or any other parts of the world who may find it difficult to navigate and adapt to a new society due to economic hardships, African immigrants’ parents are not exempt from such difficulties. It is customary for many immigrants adjusting to a new country to face challenges such as navigating an unfamiliar social structure, cultural differences, rigorous, demanding jobs, and the absence of extended family support. The question is whether we can use these challenges as an excuse for failing to meet the emotional development and unique form of nurturing our children need to thrive in a new country? African immigrant children are exposed to an educational system, an independent and individualistic mindset, and social and cultural expectations daily that are certainly different from those of their parents who spent their developmental stages in their respective African countries.
Raising children in America or in Europe does not mean that African parents must abandon their cultural values and totally surrender their parental authority. Our cultural values emphasize respect for elders, family responsibility, discipline, hard work, and, most importantly, cultural identity. All these values build good character, leading to functioning as responsible, contributing adults in society, but parents have to remodel. We adjust to the new environment by incorporating both the emotional and psychological needs of our children as they grow up in a different environment. African immigrant parents should question their parental skills by asking themselves the following questions.
1. Have we invested enough time in getting to know our children beyond their academic achievements?
2. Do our children feel comfortable discussing their emotional struggles with us with confidence of not being judged, or attentively listening to their concerns?
3. Are we raising our children to fill the gap of achievement we could not achieve, or are we raising them to be independent thinkers?
4. Are we misunderstanding the difference between obedience and a healthy relationship with our children?
5. Are we more concerned about the community’s judgment of our parental style and our children’s achievements than the emotional welfare of our children?
Thought-Provoking arguments:
As immigrant parents, have we asked ourselves or explored the differences between parental sacrifice and parental presence? Many of us measure our parental sacrifice and financial support by how much we spend in providing materially for our children. We accomplish this financial support by working long hours, holding on to multiple jobs, and some of us seeking high-paying jobs that take time away from spending quality time with our children. Some of us have this competitive mindset of buying the most expensive house than our peers, even when it is beyond our financial means, and as a result, we end up working extra hours. A big house can never replace an active parent, and many children would rather live in a small space with emotionally present parents. Children thrive on emotional support, quality time, and meaningful relationships, valuing genuine connection far more than material luxuries that upgrade our social standing among friends and family.
One-directional knowledge is one of the problems that alienates children from having close relationships with their parents, and this parenting approach is very common in African immigrants’ parenting style. Many parents are unwilling to learn from their children, and as a result, parents are always the teachers and children must always be the students. Many may attach this belief system to African culture, and I would not completely agree with this as a factual traditional practice. There is a proverb in Yoruba that says “Ọmọdé gbọ́n, àgbà gbọ́n, la fi dá Ilé-Ifẹ̀.” means that great accomplishments require the combined wisdom of both the young and the old. It teaches that no single generation holds a monopoly on intelligence, and true progress happens through mutual respect and collaboration. We must be willing to learn from our children as they grow up in this new environment. When we are open to learning from our children, we can understand some of their struggles, including mental health, identity struggles, peer pressure, the balancing act of growing up in two different cultures, known as code-switching, bullying, and their experience with discrimination. By opening up and allowing our children to express their emotions and struggles, we parents may be able to relate to some of their struggles and collectively coordinate efforts to come up with better solutions in talking through our challenges as a family unit.
We must not become the generation of African immigrants that successfully crossed the African border to overcome economic barriers and built material wealth in a country of plenty, but failed to build emotional connection with our own children.
2 Replies to “We Crossed Oceans for a Better Future, But Are We Still Parenting as Though We never Left Africa?”
The law of the land had to be followed. Most our discipline method will be considered as an abused.
Thank you for reading the article and sharing your perspective.
I agree that we must follow the laws of the land in which we live. However, the article is not about taking away reasonable discipline from the home or suggesting that parents should not establish boundaries for their children. It is about building emotional connections with our children while maintaining parental guidance, authority, and expectations.
As African immigrant parents, we must recognize that building an emotional relationship with our children does not mean abandoning discipline or allowing negative behavior to go without consequences. It means understanding that we do not necessarily have to replicate the disciplinary methods we experienced growing up in Africa when raising our children in a different cultural and social environment.
There are different approaches to parenting in every society. Some parents rely on harsh or extreme forms of punishment, while others take a more moderate approach, using conversations, explanations, and appropriate consequences to correct behavior. Discipline does not have to involve fear, physical punishment, or humiliation to be effective.
Ultimately, the goal is not to raise children who simply fear their parents’ authority, but children who understand boundaries, respect, responsibility, and the reasons behind the expectations placed on them. We can maintain our cultural values while also adapting our parenting approaches to nurture healthier relationships with our children.
The law of the land had to be followed. Most our discipline method will be considered as an abused.
Thank you for reading the article and sharing your perspective.
I agree that we must follow the laws of the land in which we live. However, the article is not about taking away reasonable discipline from the home or suggesting that parents should not establish boundaries for their children. It is about building emotional connections with our children while maintaining parental guidance, authority, and expectations.
As African immigrant parents, we must recognize that building an emotional relationship with our children does not mean abandoning discipline or allowing negative behavior to go without consequences. It means understanding that we do not necessarily have to replicate the disciplinary methods we experienced growing up in Africa when raising our children in a different cultural and social environment.
There are different approaches to parenting in every society. Some parents rely on harsh or extreme forms of punishment, while others take a more moderate approach, using conversations, explanations, and appropriate consequences to correct behavior. Discipline does not have to involve fear, physical punishment, or humiliation to be effective.
Ultimately, the goal is not to raise children who simply fear their parents’ authority, but children who understand boundaries, respect, responsibility, and the reasons behind the expectations placed on them. We can maintain our cultural values while also adapting our parenting approaches to nurture healthier relationships with our children.